Catie Cakes Reviews
Reviews
5.0 out of 5 rating
5.0 out of 5 rating
66 Reviews
100% recommend it
Awards
-
![Spring]()
Spring S. Sent on 03/16/2023Choose Catie's Cakes!
My husband and I loved working with Catie for our wedding! She was so helpful with helping us decide on cake options to fit our vision and fit within our budget. Not to mention, her cakes are amazing! We got so many compliments at the wedding and are excited to dig into our frozen top layer on our one year anniversary. She also went above and beyond on the grooms cake design - managed to fit all of my husbands favorite things on it and it was a hit! -
-
Victoria B. Sent on 06/26/2022
I want more!!
Catie was beyond amazing!! Her communication to the day left me stress free! The wedding cake was a perfect lemon cake with strawberry jam filling and buttercream! The grooms cake was devoured as it was chocolate cake with salted caramel icing!! Thank you so much!!!Catie Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much, Victoria! I hope y'all had the best day ever! Thank you for letting me play a small part in it ❤️ -
-
![Shelby]()
Shelby L. Sent on 11/04/2021Delicious & Gorgeous Wedding Cake
The most delicious and beautiful cake I have ever purchased! Catie is incredible with communication as well as her craft of baking and decorating. She emulated an image we gave her and completely exceeded our expectations! Our cake was so moist and soft. Our guests raved about our cake! -
-
![Eryn]()
Eryn Sent on 08/15/2021Delicious and beautiful!
Catie was sooo great to work with! She took time to get to know exactly what we wanted and the cake and cupcakes were BEAUTIFUL and delicious! She decorated the cupcakes exactly like the Pinterest picture I sent her! Our guests had so many compliments about how good the cupcakes were. We live in WI, so we weren’t able to do a tasting but we trusted that they would be great, and they were! Highly recommend!!!! -
-
![Gaby]()
Gaby M. Sent on 07/22/2021Wonderful experience, beautiful cake!
Catie made our wedding cake for our wedding a few weekends ago. She was wonderful to work with. She was really responsive and made a beautiful cake for us that tasted AMAZING. Her cakes are so moist and so delicious. I highly recommend her red velvet cake with oreo filling. I also highly recommend working with Catie if you need a wedding cake. -
![Samantha]()
Samantha K. Sent on 06/11/2021Delicious cake!
We had our wedding cake designed and made by Catie, and it was everything we could have wanted! It was SO beautiful, and tasted amazing. Our guests raved about the cake and cupcakes! The lemon cupcakes were my absolute favorite. Several guests told me it was the best cake they had ever had, and I completely agree. Catie is so sweet, and was very helpful during the whole process. I highly recommend Catie Cakes to everyone! -
-
Chelsey A. Sent on 06/29/2021
Loved Our Cake & Cupcakes!
Catie Cakes was recommended to us by our wedding coordinator. We told she booked up fast, so we jumped on the ball as quickly as we could. From our first meeting to the weeks leading up to our wedding, Catie was so helpful in helping make sure we got our wedding cake just the way we wanted! She understood what we wanted and made it happen so beautifully. We are so glad we went with her for our wedding cake needs!
Great all around! -
-
![Lauren]()
Lauren W. Sent on 02/03/2021Beautiful and Delicious
Catie was fantastic to work with. She was quick to respond and made the tasting so much fun. The cake turned out beautifully. I almost didn’t want to cut into it! But it’s worth it. There were only 2 slices left at the end of the night, so we know plenty of people were getting seconds. Can’t wait to pull out the topper to eat in a year! -
-
![Logan]()
Logan C. Sent on 10/17/2020Beautiful & Delicious!
Catie did such an incredible job with our cake. We just wanted a simple semi-naked cake, but it truly turned out so beautiful with the floral display, and it was delicious!! We did three different crazy layers and it turned out incredible. If you’re looking for a beautiful & delicious wedding cake, look no further than Catie Cakes. -
-
![Anna]()
Anna Sent on 10/07/2020Sweet cake, Sweet Lady
Working with Catie was such a wonderful experience. She is so sweet, very responsive, and professional. Not only was our wedding cake delicious but we received so many complements that it was the best cake anyone had ever tasted! I’m not a typical bride and had 2 postponements due to illness and COVID but Catie was so easy to work with and rescheduled my dates with a breeze!
Catie welcomed us into her home to taste cake flavors and they were all so amazing I couldn’t decide. She then had an idea to use different flavor combinations on each layer and do up cakes for the rest and it turned out amazing! On the wedding day Catie delivered and sat up the cake and had it looking amazing before I even knew she was there!
I highly recommend hiring Catie Cakes for your wedding! Working with Catie is an investment you won’t regret on your wedding day! -
-
![Lisa]()
Lisa B. Sent on 09/13/2020Best wedding cake!!
Working with Catie was such a breeze! She is quick to respond to emails, totally flexible (when I kept changing my mind), and it was so fun creating our wedding cake with her. She welcomed us into her home for our cake tasting and helped us create our perfect wedding cake. I had also been secretly emailing her to create an awesome fish/groom's cake for my hubby which she totally nailed!! My husband was so surprised and she knocked my idea out of the park! I would highly recommend Catie Cakes for your big day!! -
-
![Taylor]()
Taylor Sent on 04/11/2020Most delicious cake!!!
Since the moment we met Catie to taste her cake flavors, she was so sweet and fun to work with! The cake flavors were all so good, my husband and I couldn't decide on one combination. Little did we know, Catie would let us use different combinations on different layers, so we each got what we wanted! The cake was gorgeous and tasted even better than we imagined on our wedding day! Now we are anxious for our 1 year anniversary so we can eat it again! -
-
![Dru]()
Dru B. Sent on 04/17/2020Beautiful & Delicious!
Catie made THE BEST cake I have ever eaten for our wedding! We are from Louisiana and traveled to Tennessee to get married so I was a little nervous about how the cake would taste. We did not get the chance to do a cake tasting with Catie, but she was super easy to work with throughout the whole process. We decided on a funfetti cake because who doesn't love funfetti?! And it was a HUGE success! Everyone LOVED the cake. Like, licking plates loved the cake. haha I also had loved one of her previous designs so we decided to go with that one. We originally weren't going to save the top tier since we had to travel back home, but I am SO GLAD that we did becauseeee we get to eat it again a year from now! You should have Catie make your wedding cake. Your taste buds will thank you! -
-
![Marylynne]()
Marylynne Sent on 02/20/2020Catie Cakes.. an investment you won't regret!
Catie is the sweetest (no pun intended) person you'll ever meet. All her flavors were delicious, and we knew ours wouldn't be any different! She was helpful with cake stands and all! When my planner dropped the ball for our tasting Catie met us again to make it right and we could taste the flavors we wanted. Our wedding cake was the most delicious cake I think we or any of our guests ever ate.Three months later and people still talk about it! Hopefully we can sweet talk her into some cupcakes when we can visit again! The quality of the cake was phenomenal and only thing that could compete is how beautiful and perfect it was! Working with Catie will not be an investment you'll regret! -
-
![Kayla]()
Kayla B. Sent on 11/25/2019Wedding cake/cupcakes
Catie Cakes makes the best cakes! She has so many flavor and decoration options, and they’re ALL amazing. Catie is super sweet and professional. She kept in touch with me throughout my planning process and was always helpful. Our cake and cupcakes were gorgeous, and Catie even decorated our cake for us. Trust me, you want these cakes! -
-
![Jessie and Justin]()
Jessie Sent on 11/16/2019Great Service and Great Cake!
We can not express enough about our cake. We ordered a wedding cake for our reception for November 3rd 2019. Not only was she able to deliver to us on a Sunday, but her customer service is top notch. I never had a hard time reaching her. I never felt rushed or in any kind of bind with her. I even had my Mr. make out cake toper.... it ended up being a bit over the top , but she made it all work! My breath was taken away when I saw the finished product on the table.
Most people can not say there cake looked and tasted amazing. We sure can! I had quite a few people cancel the day of or day before so planning a cake for 80 people, I was a bit scared I would have so much left over, not the case at all. So many people liked it enough we had no cake left over! It was a little sweet for me 100% personally, but my guests are still raving about our wedding cake. -
Elizabeth Sent on 11/09/2019
Best cake I’ve ever had - seriously
Catie was wonderful to work with, very responsive and sweet. I probably changed my mind 3 times about our cake design before our wedding and she was awesome every time.
Not only was our cake beautiful, it was delicious. I wouldn’t consider my fiancé or I “cake people”, but we were blown away by our wedding cake and so were our guests. We loved it so much we ate the leftovers all honeymoon long. -
-
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 10/11/2019Perfect Wedding Cake
If you are searching for the perfect wedding cake, we highly recommend Catie Cakes!! We can't say enough good things about her! She has such a large amount of flavors to pick from and the ones we went with were absolutely delicious. Our cake looked perfect and the cupcakes were so much fun. She is very fun to work with and will help you create your dream wedding cake! -
![Joanna]()
Joanna B. Sent on 11/05/2019Sunflower Cake & Cookies
Catie did an exceptional job on our cake and sugar cookie favors! Not only did they look stunning but tasted delicious too! Catie was a joy to work with and was always happy to answer our questions and requests in a timely manner. -
-
![Rebecca]()
Rebecca Sent on 08/01/2019Delicious cake and a delight to work with!
Catie is an absolute delight to work with! She's professional, so friendly, and kind throughout the entire process. She was communicative, punctual, and went above and beyond in her creation of the cake. Her creative spirit and incredible baking skills shine through her impressive work. Our cake was both gorgeous and (more importantly) DELICIOUS. All our guests continue to gush about how moist, perfectly crumbly, and flavorful our lemon berry cake was. Many of our guests have gone out of their way to explain that they're 'not usually cake people' if given the choice, but that they absolutely loved our wedding cake! Catie made our vision for flavors and aesthetic come alive and we couldn't be happier! -
![Juliana]()
Juliana Sent on 09/24/2019Best wedding cake EVER!
Catie is nothing short of amazing! Not only is she such a pleasure to work with but she has the most amazing cakes I've ever tasted. Before my wedding, I met with her and told her how important the wedding cake was to us and she was so understanding and willing to work extremely hard to live up to our expectations. Even after all my design changes, she was always such a joy to work with. Of all the things at my wedding, the wedding cake was one of my absolute favorites. Not only was it BEAUTIFUL but it was the best tasting cake I have ever eaten. We got lemon with blackberry filling and cream cheese icing. It was to die for. I had guests telling me for weeks how amazing the cake was. It was so good that I had to order a set of cupcakes in the same flavor just a couple months after the wedding because we wanted more :) All in all, Catie blew me away and I would recommend her to anyone! -
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message