Sarah's Cake Shop Reviews
Reviews
4.8 out of 5 rating
81 Reviews
96%
Recommended by couples
Awards
-
![Cody]()
Cody Sent on 10/29/2019Ms Cody Eckelkamp
Sarah’s was amazing! Very accommodating and flexible with our cake design and flavors. There was anything they couldn’t help us with or do for us. Our guests absolutely loved the cake! My husband and I actually didn’t even get to eat any of it because of the craziness of the night but we are looking forward to trying it on our one year when Sarah’s makes us a fresh cake! We had so many compliments about how good it was!Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Yay! These pictures are great! Thanks so much Cody for such kind words! We are so happy you loved everything! I'm sorry you didn't get much cake the night of but yes on looking forward to that anniversary cake! :) Thank you for choosing to work with us here at Sarah's! It was such a pleasure to work with you! Please let us know if you should need anything! Thanks again and Congratulations!
Best Wishes, Sarah Como-Wedding Coordinator -
-
Kelly M. Sent on 10/08/2019
Beautiful and Delicious
Sarah’s Cake Shop did an amazing job on our wedding cake. Not only did it look beautiful, but it was absolutely delicious! We got many compliments.Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Yay! Thanks so much Kelly! Your cake looked amazing and we loved your custom toppers! So cute! Thank you so much for choosing to work with Sarah's Cake Shop for your wedding! It was such a pleasure to work with you! Please let us know if we can ever be of assistance! Thanks again and Congratulations!
Best Wishes,
Sarah Como-Wedding Coordinator -
-
![Laura]()
Laura Sent on 08/24/2019Best Cake Ever
We tried countless bakeries for our wedding and when we discovered Sarah's Cake Shop, our search was over! This was such an easy planning process and their cake tastes AMAZING! They have so many flavors of cake and icing. The cake turned out more beautiful than I could have imagined. They even make a replica top of the cake for your one year anniversary! We will definitely be using Sarah's again in the future!Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Laura,
Thank you so much for such kind words! Wow the cake looks amazing! We are so pleased to hear that you loved the cake in all aspects for your big day! It was such a pleasure to work with you both and I wish you a lifetime of happiness! We will see you next year for your yummy anniversary cake! Please let us know if you should ever need anything!
Thanks again! Best Wishes!
Sarah Como-Wedding Coordinator -
-
Susan Sent on 09/26/2018As a person with a major sweet tooth, I could not be happier with Sarah’s Cake Shop. Everything from setting up tasting appointments to the day of delivery was easy, fast, and stress free. For our wedding we ordered a small 2 tiered cake and 200 cupcakes for our guests. Sarah’s Cake Shop was able to recreate the cake from a photo off of Pinterest. Everyone loved the cupcakes as well. Everything looked beautiful and tasted delicious. Thanks Sarah’s Cake Shop!
Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Susan,
Wow look at that cake! So amazing! Thank you so much for choosing to work with Sarah's Cake Shop for your big day! We are so happy to hear that everyone enjoyed everything! It was such a pleasure working with you and we hope everything about your wedding was spectacular! Please let us know if you ever need anything! Thanks again for your business!
Best Wishes,
Sarah Como-Wedding Coordinator -
-
Elizabeth Sent on 12/26/2017We only wanted a small decorative cake to cut into because of other desserts being made by our families. Unlike other cake shops, Sarah's didn't press us to order a larger cake than we wanted. They are also flexible on their flavors, we requested a buttercream flavor they didn't normally do but they were happy to accommodate us! My only regret is that I didn't have our caterers keep a few pieces of the cake back for my husband and I; it was all gone before we came back to the dessert table! Thankfully, they also provide a complimentary 6" round cake for your first anniversary so we'll get to have some then (and IMO that's so much better than eating the stale top layer a year afterwords)!
Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Elizabeth,
Thank you so much for the kind words! We are so glad that you were happy with the cake! It is important to us here at Sarah's that we provide what you want in a cake whether it's big or small, elaborate or simple! I wish you would have had leftovers but I am happy to hear you are looking forward to your fresh complimentary anniversary cake! :) Thanks for allowing Sarah's to be apart of your special day! Please don't hesitate to reach out if you should ever need anything!
Best Wishes,
Sarah Como- Wedding Coordinator -
-
April Sent on 11/26/2017Simply delicious!
Having an amazing cake was important to us. We attended quite a few wedding shows during the planning period at one of the shows a vendor had Sarah's glitter bites as a thanks for stopping by, as soon as we ate that we fell in love. We have since visited Sarah's Cake shop a few times and everything there is delicious. We wanted to make sure we had the best at our wedding and we went to a lot of St. Louis bakeries for cake tastings and no one could beat Sarah's cake shop. The cakes are moist and flavorful, the icing is so good, not too sweet and just leave you wanting more(alot of times I can't eat the icing, it's just too much but not with Sarah's!) Their styles range from simple top over the top fancy. We opted for simple and couldn't have been happier. We had a 3 tier cake 2 tiers were almond and 1 tier was Vanilla cake and icing with a cream cheese center. Sarah's made the cakes so that you couldn't tell the different flavors so that people weren't taking extra pieces which we wanted so we could have a bit of left overs.
We also had glitter bites as favors and everyone is still raving over them!
Thanks also to Sarah who helped us with our tasting and decisions making. Sarah you made it so easy!Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Wow April! How so very sweet of you! Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a thoughtful review! I am so pleased that everything turned out just like you wanted it! The cake looked beautiful and I personally always love the simple route! :)
Thank you for allowing Sarah's to be apart of your special day! Make sure to stop by and see us now and then for a sweet treat fix! Please feel free to reach out if you should ever need anything! It was such a pleasure to work with you!
Thanks again!
Best Wishes,
Sarah Como- Wedding Coordinator -
-
Amy Sent on 10/25/2017Oh My Delicious!!!! We could not have been happier with our wedding cake experience with Sarah's. From the tasting to the real deal at the reception; everything regarding our cake was flawless.
We were on the hunt for a non-fondant bakery for our wedding cake. We tasted cakes from 4 different bakeries and not only was Sarah's the best, taste wise, it was also the best price wise as well! We wanted a simply iced, 3-tier cake to which we would add florals and what was delivered was exactly what I had envisioned. We opted for two flavors (one for the actual tiered cake and one for the "kitchen cake"). We went with the traditional white wedding cake - which was outstanding, as well as a chocolate cake with a raspberry buttercream - it was decadently delicious! We were so impressed by the "Kitchen Cakes" from Sarah's - they were multiple layered cakes that, when sliced, truly look as though they were cut from the big cake.
We have had multiple guests compliment our wedding cake. We did end up with leftovers (which was totally our fault due to anticipating a larger guest count) however, it ended up being a happy accident because we got to enjoy or wedding cake over and over until it was all gone. Sarah's Cake Shop has gained a new loyal customer in me. beautifully decorated desserts, delicious cake, and wonderful customer service. Thanks Sarah's!!!Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Wow Amy! The cake looks beautiful! Props to your florist as well! :)
Thank you so much for choosing Sarah's to provide for your wedding! We greatly appreciate your business and look forward to working with you again in the future for some possible birthday cakes, or daily sweet treats! :)
We are so happy to hear the cake was amazing and lived up to your expectations! Please feel free to contact me if you should ever need anything! Thanks again!
Best Wishes,
Sarah Como, Wedding Coordinator -
-
![Blair Waldorf]()
Coti Sent on 11/05/2017Sarah's Cake shop did a beautiful job on our cake! From our custom created tier to turning my favorite snack cake cupcake they sell into a tier of our cake, they went above and beyond our expectations! Everybody was raving about the cake! This is a business that we will gladly continue to do business with in the future.Sarah's Cake Shop's reply:
Coti,
Thank you so much for such kind words! We absolutely loved making this cake! So unique and beautiful! We are so happy to hear the cake tasted as great as it looked too! Who doesn't love a good Snack Cake cupcake/cake!? We hope your wedding was nothing short of amazing! Thank you so much for letting us be apart of your special day! We look forward to working with you again for birthdays and daily sweet treats! Thanks again!
Best Wishes,
Sarah Como-Wedding Coordinator -
-
User2852535 Sent on 11/06/2016Our cake was so delicious! All our guest loved the cupcakes! We got so many compliments and questions on where we got our cake from! -
![Nichole]()
Nichole Sent on 10/22/2016My first experience with Sarah's was their cupcake truck. I'd never heard of them and was newly engaged so I bought a cupcake and their "everyday wedding cake". It was amazing! So...I went out to their website and here to see if they did weddings and sure enough, they do.
A couple tastings later, we hadn't found anyone we liked better. What sold me is the buttercream frosting. Anyone can make a good cake but not everyone has good frosting. Being a baker myself, I wasn't about to serve anything at our wedding that wasn't as good or better than something I could make myself. Sarah's was the only one I found that met that requirement! I even passed up a 10% discount and free delivery from our venue's preferred vendor to have them. If that doesn't speak for the quality of their cake, I don't know what else will.
They were so accommodating, I can't count the number of times I changed our cake order before finally settling on the final product and paying. Every time, Heather was so nice and understanding...whether it was coming up with a design change to eliminate fondant or changing the order after our RSVP's came in.
The day we picked up our 3 tiered cake, they had it boxed in such a way that it wouldn't move or touch the sides and ruin the frosting. It arrived in perfect condition. And...to say our guests were raving about the cake is an understatement. If you haven't chosen your cake yet, give them a try! You won't regret it.
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message